CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Survey
The Disability Divide:
The gap between what employees believe-and how they act-about the potential for an income-threatening disability.
THE STATE OF DISABILITY IN AMERICA
Continued economic volatility. Rising home foreclosures. Eroded retirement accounts. Stubbornly high unemployment. All have heightened American workers’ sensitivity to the need for a reliable stream of income and financial security. Yet most don’t realize a disability could interrupt their income-and fewer still are protected from that loss by adequate savings, private insurance OR government programs.
Just consider these recent statistics on disability in America.
Over 10% of Americans between the ages of 18 and 64 have a disability1
8.1 million U.S. workers receive Social Security
Disability (SSDI) benefit as of October 20102
Nearly 90% of disabilities aren’t work-related
and therefore don’t qualify for workers’ compensation benefits3
Applications for Social Security
Disability Benefits (SSDI) increased 21%
from 2008 and are projected to increase in 2010 as well4
Only 35% of initial SSDI applications
were approved in 20094
100 million Americans are not protected
by private disability insurance5
1U.S. Census Bureau, Selected Social Characteristics in the United States: 2009. 2SSA Beneficiary Data, October, 2010. 3National Safety Council,
Injury Facts, 2008 edition. 4Social Security Administration, Office of Disability and Income Security Programs. 5Council for Disability Awareness,
Long-Term Disability Claims Review, 2005.
How aware are today’s employees of their chances of facing an incomeinterrupting
disability? And how prepared are they to deal with the financial
consequences if they do experience one? Those were just two of the key
questions the Council for Disability Awareness (CDA) set out to address in
its 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness study.
To answer these important questions, the Council for Disability Awareness (CDA) conducted
an online survey with a nationwide panel of wage-earning consumers. These questions were
designed to:
- Understand workers’ perceptions about disability
- Identify actual behaviors related to these perceptions
- Determine the level of preparation workers have taken to protect themselves
and their families from the risk of suffering a disability
- Learn to what extent workers are positioned to deal with an income loss caused
by an illness or accident
We hope the insights gleaned from this research will help employees, employers and financial
advisors alike bridge the divide between what employees think and what they do-as well as
between what they perceive and what is real. It’s this divide that leaves too many Americans
and their financial security at risk from a disability-triggered loss of income.
Survey Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
Summary of Findings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Divide #1: Beliefs about disability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Divide #2: Overall odds of becoming disabled. . . . . . . . . . . 5
Divide #3: Causes of disability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Divide #4: Protection against disability. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Divide #5: Duration of disability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
Divide #6: Preparation for disability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Divide #7: Income sources in event of disability. . . . . . . . . 11
Conclusion. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
2
This research study conducted in
March 2010 analyzed the responses of
1,006 representative employees who
met the following four screening criteria:
• U.S. residents
• Employed full-time
• Between the ages of 18 and 68
• Household income of $30,000 or more
Participants were part of MarketTools ZoomPanel
and each participant received an incentive from
MarketTools to participate in the survey. All
respondents took the survey between March 23
and March 26, 2010. The CDA 2010 Consumer
Disability Awareness Survey was conducted online.
RESPONDENTS BY GENDER
RESPONDENTS BY INCOME LEVEL
52%
Females
48%
Males
> $25K
$25-49K
$50-99K
$100-149K
$150-249K
$250-500K
$500+K
RESPONDENTS BY AGE
18-24 3%
7%
10%
9%
17%
13%
19%
11%
11%
25-29
30-34
35-39
40-44
45-49
50-54
55-59
60+
2%
23%
47%
17%
8%
2%
1%
Overview of survey methodology
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
The results of the 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Survey highlight one key fact: most
individuals still underestimate or deny their own chances of becoming disabled. Even more
noteworthy, and quite frankly, more troubling, they underprepare for the potentially devastating
financial impact on themselves and their families. Here are some other aspects of the great divide
this research identified between workers’ general perceptions about disability-and their
willingness to prepare for what it could mean to them personally.
“It’s likely to happen, but not to me.”
83% said a disability could happen to anyone at any time but deny it will specifically happen to them.
“My income is critical, but protecting it isn’t.”
90% say they value their ability to earn an income, but almost 40% said they haven’t thought about
how they would protect this all-important financial resource.
“I think disabilities tend to last a year or more, but I could only cover my bills for
three months or less.”
Almost 70% of survey respondents said a disability would keep a person out of work for more than
one year, but 38% said they could only pay bills for three months or less if they lost their income.
“I think most disabilities are caused by accidents.”
More than 70% say a disability (which prevents them from working) would likely be caused by a serious
accident, when more than 90% of disabilities are actually caused by illness.
“My chances of becoming disabled are slim.”
44% say they have about a 1% chance of becoming disabled during their working years. Yet the
chances are actually about 30% that workers in their 20s will experience a long-term disability prior
to retirement.
“If I get sick, my benefits will cover my expenses.”
42% said their primary source to replace lost wages would be money from sick/vacation leave benefits
from their employer. But these benefits are poorly understood and typically last only a matter of weeks.
While it appears that workers generally seem to understand the potential long-lasting impact a disability
may cause, many avoid taking actions that could help them personally deal with that impact. This and
other key findings about “the disability divide” between employees’ perceptions and reality as well as
their beliefs and actions are detailed on the following pages.
Highlights of survey findings
3
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
A significant number of respondents
consider themselves less vulnerable to
a disability than the population at large.
This may indicate an inability, even an unwillingness,
for most people to view their present health (which they
tend to rate as “good”) as something that is susceptible
to change. In short, they’re “in denial.”
What’s also interesting is that women rank the average
American’s likelihood of becoming disabled higher than
men did. Yet women rank their own odds of becoming
disabled lower than men do. So on average, women
think men are more likely to become disabled when
in reality, at most ages, women are more likely to suffer
from one.
83% of respondents think that a
disability could happen to “anyone
at any time.”
- Only 5% of the survey’s respondents said it
happens infrequently.
- Probably because most respondents viewed
disability as “accidental,” only 6% think that
they can do anything to avoid it, such as living
a healthy lifestyle.
Employees believe
that others can become
disabled at anytime.
Employees deny
that disabilities are likely
to happen to them.
RESEARCH FINDINGS:
% of respondents who selected each of the following statements as reflective of their own beliefs about disability
83%
“Most people who become disabled have inherited certain traits
that cause them to be that way.”
“Disabilities are usually the result of someone being careless.”
“It happens infrequently.”
“Most disabilities can be avoided through healthy lifestyles.”
“Other
6
5
3
2
1
“It can happen to anyone at any time.”
4
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
The Social Security Administration
estimates that 3 out of 10 Americans
entering the workforce today will
become disabled before they retire.
This statistic is supported by the Council for Disability
Awareness Personal Disability Quotient (PDQ)
calculator as well as publicly available actuarial
tables. See www.whatsmypdq.org for details.
The PDQ calculates the odds of being disabled for a
healthy 35- to 45-year-old male during his working
career as about 1 in 6.*
*Calculated by the Council for Disability Awareness’ “Personal Disability
Quotient” (PDQ) for males, 5′ 10″, 185 pounds, with no tobacco use and
about average health.
Workers significantly underestimate
either others’ or their own chances of
becoming disabled.
- Over half of survey respondents think only one in
100 or one in 50 working Americans are likely to
become disabled during their working careers.
- Only 7% of the survey respondents came close to
predicting their chances accurately.
- Those who knew someone who had been disabled
were much more likely to think there was a higher
chance they’d become disabled. In fact 27% of this
group thought their own odds were at least 1 in 10.
Employees estimate
only 1% will become
disabled before retirement.
Actuaries project
the odds of being disabled
at least 10 times higher.
RESEARCH FINDINGS:
respondents’ estimate of the chances of becoming disabled
31%
23%
23%
14%
5%
4%
1 in 100
1 in 50
1 in 25
1 in 10
1 in 5
1 in 3
the “average”
American
44%
20%
14%
10%
5%
7%
INDUSTRY STATISTIC:
actual chances that an employee entering
the workforce will experience a long-term
disability prior to retirement
% of respondents who
believed these were the odds
of becoming disabled for:
“me”
odds of
becoming
disabled
5
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
Disability insurance industry statistics report
that fewer than one out of 10 long-term
claims actually result from injuries.
The CDA 2010 Long-Term Disability Claim Review reports:
- More than one out of four income-interrupting
disabilities are triggered by muscle and bone disorders
such as back problems, joint pain and muscle pain.
- Cancer is the second leading cause of new disability
claims, representing 15% of all claims.
- Cardiovascular/circulatory problems have increased
slightly and are now the third leading cause of new
and existing disability claims.
- Most disabilities are not work-related, and therefore
not covered by workers’ compensation.
- Lifestyle choices and personal behavior that lead to
obesity are becoming major contributing factors.
71% of respondents believe
that disability is most likely caused by
serious accidents.
In general, employees tended to see disability as
resulting from a more “catastrophic” cause-serious
accidents, stroke, cancer, heart disease and paralysis.
They tended to overlook more commonplace causes
such as muscle or bone pain and chronic disease.
- 45% of employees cited a stroke as a likely cause
of disability.
- 43% said cancer was a likely cause.
- 40% said heart disease would cause a
potential disability.
Employees think
most disabilities are
caused by injuries.
Serious accident
71%
Injuries
9%
EMPLOYEE PERCEPTIONS:
% of employees who think disabilities are very or
somewhat likely to be caused by a serious accident
INDUSTRY STATISTICS:
% of long-term disabilities that were actually
caused by injuries and poisoning accidents in 2009
Studies show
most disabilities are
caused by illnesses.
Source: The CDA 2010 Long-Term Disability Claim Review.
6
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
THE DISABILITY DIVIDE: CAUSES OF DISABILITY (CONTINUED)
Attitudinal differences by gender
Men and women have a somewhat different view of
what would cause disability.
In general, women think their own chances of
becoming disabled are lower in six out of 10
categories than their male counterparts. Even so,
they estimated their own chances of becoming
disabled higher than men in four categories:
- serious accident
- cancer
- muscle or bone pain
- depression/anxiety
Attitudinal difference by income
While few employees named lifestyle and substance
abuse as likely causes of disability, it’s interesting to
note that both were cited more often by respondents
who earn $250,000 or more per year.
EMPLOYEE PERCEPTIONS:
% of employees who rated each cause for
disability as “very” or “somewhat likely”
Serious accident
Stroke
Cancer
Heart disease
Paralysis
Injuries at work
Muscle or bone pain
Depression/anxiety
Lifestyle
Substance abuse
26% Musculoskeletal/Connective Tissue Disorders
15% Cancer and Neoplasms
9% Cardiovascular/Circulatory Disorders
9% Injuries and Poisoning
8% Complications of Pregnancy, Childbirth
and the Puerperium
8% Mental Disorders
7% Nervous System-Related
4% Other
3% Digestive System-Related
3% Symptoms, Signs and Ill-Defined
2% Respiratory System Disorders
2% Genitourinary System Disorders
1% Endocrine, Nutritional and Metabolic
Diseases and Immunity Disorders
1% Infections and Parasitic Diseases
1% Skin and Subcutaneous Tissue Disorders
71%
40%
32%
32%
14%
12%
8%
INDUSTRY STATISTICS:
% of new long-term disability claims caused
by each of the following
“New” claims are those approved in the survey year.
Source: The 2010 CDA Long-Term Disability Claim Review.
45%
43%
26%
7
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
Employees do
believe a disability would
interrupt their income.
Employees don’t
have the resources to
replace that income.
More than half said they’d only be able
to pay their bills for a year or less if their
income stopped.
For most, an income-limiting disability would most
likely result in the rapid depletion of their resources.
In fact, 65% said that they would only be able
to pay bills for less than a year if their income stopped.
And when asked where income would come from to
pay bills, many responses seemed vague and dubious.
Other findings support how unprepared most
Americans are to deal with an interruption in income.
- Many U.S. families spend more than they earn.1
- Only 40% of adult Americans have savings
ear-marked for emergencies.2
- 71% of American employees live from paycheck to
paycheck,3 without enough savings to cushion the
financial blow of a disability.
More than half of the survey respondents
equated disability with the inability to work
for a living.
- 57%, or more than half, of the workers surveyed
said that to be disabled would mean they would
be unable to work.
- 30% had the most negative view of disability as
being “incapable of functioning.”
- While only a few believed that a disability would
mean the “end of life worth living,” almost all
had a catastrophic view of disability.
EMPLOYEE PERCEPTIONS:
% of people who define disability
as each of the following
EMPLOYEE REALITIES:
% of respondents who could continue to pay bills
with no income
Not being
able to work
More than
1 year
Less than
1 year
Incapable of
functioning
Unable to do
what is normal
Depending on
others for help 13 57% %
35%
65%
10%
5%
1Federal Reserve Board, Survey of Consumer Finances, 2004.
2Consumer Federation of America, national survey by Opinion Research Corp., Feb. 2007.
3American Payroll Association, “Getting Paid in America” Survey, 2008.
8
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
Employees think
most disabilities will
last a long time.
Studies show
most don’t have long-term
disability protection.
Nearly 70% of respondents think a
disability would keep a person out of
work for more than one year.
Workers surveyed believe that if a person becomes
disabled, he/she will be out of work for a lengthy period
of time. In fact, more than two-thirds of respondents
thought that a disability would put a person out of
work for a year or more. And almost one-third said
that person would never return to work.
70% of employees in the private sector
are not covered by any type of private
long-term disability insurance.1
In fact, even when offered as a voluntary benefit by
their employers, almost 40% of workers don’t choose
long-term disability insurance.2 And barely 30% claim
to understand it very well.2
Even the likelihood of receiving government benefits
from the Social Security Disability Insurance program
(SSDI), which could cover a person after a severe
disability that is expected to last a year or more or
result in death, is dwindling. Although most private sector
employees are covered by SSDI, benefits are limited.
- The average monthly SSDI benefit amount in 2009
was $1,064, with 56% of recipients receiving less
than $1,000 per month.3
- It is very difficult to qualify for SSDI benefits. 65% of
initial benefit applications were denied in 2009,3 and
the appeals process can last up to four years.
- SSDI approval rates have steadily declined in
recent years.4
1Social Security Administration, Fact Sheet, Jan. 31, 2007.
2CDA 2008 Worker Disability Planning and Preparedness Study.
3Social Security Administration, Disabled Worker Beneficiary Statistics, ssa.gov.
4The 2010 CDA Long-Term Disability Claims Survey.
EMPLOYEE PERCEPTIONS:
% of respondents who believed that a disability typically
lasts the following lengths of time
1%
7%
14%
9%
20%
9%
8%
31%
Less than 1 month
1 to 3 months
4 to 6 months
7 to 11 months
1 to 2 years
2 to 5 years
More than 5 years
Most likely never
to return to work
68%estimated
more than one year
Nearly 1 out of 3 estimated that
a disability would prevent someone
from ever working again
9
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
Employees do think
their ability to earn an
income is valuable.
Employees don’t think
about taking steps to
protect that income.
While nearly all employees say their ability
to earn an income is important, fewer than
40% have thought about protecting it.
When asked about how they’ve prepared for a potential
disability, survey respondents generally admitted
that they’ve not taken much action to prepare.
- The most common answer, given by 37% of the
respondents, was “I’ve never really thought about it.”
- Only 22% said they don’t think about it because they
have disability insurance.
90% of respondents rated their ability
to earn an income as “valuable” or
“very valuable.”
Clearly, workers highly value their ability to earn
an income. In fact, almost all respondents rated
this ability as more valuable than other financial
resources which help them achieve financial security,
including retirement savings, personal possessions,
homes and medical insurance.
HOW EMPLOYEES ACT:
% of respondents who are prepared for a disability
WHAT EMPLOYEES VALUE:
financial resources rated valuable by respondents
Retirement savings
Home
Savings and investments
other than retirement savings
Medical insurance
Other insurance
Personal possessions
90% 37%
43
57
76
77
79
80
“I don’t think about it because
I have disability insurance.”
“Disability won’t last long, so
there’s no real need to plan.”
“I have enough savings to cover
my bills.”
13
20
22
Ability to earn an income
“I’ve never really thought about
protecting my income.”
10
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
Employees think
they’re covered for income
loss by some other source.
Employees don’t realize
they can’t count on outside
sources of income.
Sick leave and vacation are typically
short-term solutions that run out in a
matter of weeks.
Other top answers employees gave also seem to reveal
a lack of understanding about what income sources
could actually pay the bills in the event they
became disabled.
- 36% cited a partner’s income as a source of income.
But if two incomes are needed to meet expenses,
simply relying on just one most likely wouldn’t be
enough, at least for a time. In addition, many spouses
take on a caregiver role and work less when the other
becomes disabled.
- 34% said they would take on more debt. But there’s
little chance of qualifying for a loan when someone
is disabled and unable to earn an income to pay the
money back. While credit card debt was also cited
as an option, it is notoriously expensive, and would
be difficult to pay off because, again, there would
be no income to make required payments.
EMPLOYEE REACTIONS:
Where would the money come from to pay bills?
Source of Income % ranked 1st, 2nd or 3rd highest
Employer payments for
sick leave and vacation
Disability insurance
payments
Your spouse or
partner’s income
Debt
Help from friends
or family
Selling possessions
Retirement savings
account
Government programs
Household savings
34%
32%
32%
30%
24%
38%
42%
36%
31%
11
When asked what source they’d likely tap in
the event they became disabled and couldn’t
work, 40% of employees said they would
rely on employer-funded sick/vacation leave.
Other perceived top sources of income included
disability insurance payments, and a spouse’s or partner’s
income and debt. But most responses seemed “off the
cuff” and many of the sources cited are probably not
sufficient to cover living expenses.
What’s also interesting to note is that Gen Y respondents
were more likely than other groups to consider
tapping into their retirement savings-not likely to be
a significant asset at this stage in their careers.
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
CONCLUSION
The findings highlighted in this report suggest that consumers like you need to
become better educated on how likely it is that an illness or injury could force you
out of work, and to get better prepared for what you can do to mitigate this loss.
Consider these steps to help understand the devastating consequences of a
disability-and enhance your financial preparedness.
Learn more about disability.
Consumers need more of an education to: 1) correct the many misconceptions surrounding disability;
and 2) learn about what you can do to lower the risk of its financial impact. An enlightening and
easy-to-use online tool called the Personal Disability Quotient available from the CDA at
www.whatsmypdq.org can help raise your awareness.
Know your benefits.
Our findings showed that the workers in this survey have a poor understanding of their benefit
programs and incorrectly think vacation/disability paid leaves will get them through an extended period
of no income. Spend time reviewing what disability benefits you already have through your employer,
how each one works and the maximum benefit you’re entitled to receive from each one. Determine your
sources of post-disability income, and whether they will be sufficient to meet your financial obligations
in the event that a disability forces you to stop working for a time.
Take action.
Although the survey showed that workers claim “disability can happen to anyone at any time,” they
haven’t taken any steps to prepare themselves financially. Make sure you take charge of your own
health-both physical and financial.
Talk to an expert.
This study showed that overall knowledge for disability planning among workers is not sufficient.
And judging by how few have taken action, it doesn’t appear to be very highly valued either. Partner
with financial experts, human resource professionals at work and other trusted advisors who can
help you design, implement and communicate appropriate solutions to protect your income-and
financial security.
Resources
www.whatsmypdq.org
www.disabilitycanhappen.org
email: feedback@disabilitycouncil.org
phone: 207-774-2634
12
CDA 2010 Consumer Disability Awareness Study
www.disabilitycanhappen.org